The researchers applied their theory in sports medicine to show how a placebo analgesic affected the pain endurance after an injury.
Qualitative Critique Descriptive Vividness The authors explicitly stated the purpose of the study as outlined in the statement of purpose. With regard to the congruency of the transcripts with the themes under study, it is apparent that the excerpts obtained from transcripts were congruent with the themes under discussion.
For instance, the participants consisted of five first-time breastfeeding women who has uncomplicated deliveries and had stayed in the hospital for at least a day after childbirth. This indicates a high degree of congruency between the transcripts and the themes under study, which relates to breastfeeding.
All of the participants expressed a number of difficulties with breastfeeding and reported that prenatal classes were not helpful in preventing the difficulties such as poor latching of the baby, which results in painful and sore nipples Adewale, The transcripts provided a channel through which the researcher could address the underlying research questions Qualitative critique of psychology paper meet the objectives.
In addition, the researcher attempted to relate the results to the existing literature, particularly with regard to the importance of breastfeeding. Overall, it can be argued that the interview guide questions were congruent with the identified themes, which is clearly outlined in the Table1 titled correlation of the interview guide questions to the identified themes.
Methodological Congruence With regard to the documentation of participants, it is evident that the author provided a sufficient documentation of the participants.
For instance, the breastfeeding women who participated in the research ranged from years, and had stayed in Canada for a minimum of three years. With regard to the attention to procedural approach, it is evident that the researcher failed to identify a philosophical base of the study.
However, it is evident that there was sufficient trust between the researcher and the participants. The researcher also documented the data collection methods and procedures Adewale, For instance, all participants in the study were asked the same basic questions and the interview was guided by a semi structured approach.
The researcher also used an interview guide using open ended questions, with each interview lasting for one hour, which is adequate. It can be concluded that the study had minimal methodological flaws.
With regard to the adherence of ethical standards, the researcher took into consideration the principle of voluntary participation and confidentiality. For instance, participation in the study was voluntary, and the researcher reminded the participants that the meeting in their respective homes was confidential.
In addition, the researcher guaranteed no harm to the participants since there were no anticipated risks associated with taking part in the study. Moreover, the researcher informed the participants of the study and their involvement.
Regarding auditability, there is a link between the findings presented and the data collected, which implies that the researcher used the collected data to make conclusions. In addition, the study has presented enough participant quotes that can be used to substantiate the findings.
Analytical and Interpretive Preciseness The analysis of the data collected was done by the extraction and synthesis process that started by sorting the data to determine the themes, after which the researcher identified the themes.
In this study, the researcher did not outline any research philosophy when describing the research methods and procedures. Nevertheless, there is a clear connection between the data and nursing practice.
It is also evident that the findings are consistent with the common experiences. Adewale also correlated the findings of the study with the existing body of knowledge by comparing and contrasting the findings of the study with the findings of other studies.
In the Relationship of the Results to the Literature section, Adewale sufficiently examined existing body of knowledge relating to the phenomenon under study. Regarding the applicability of the findings to nursing practice, research and education, it is evident that the findings of the study are relevant to nursing.
In addition, the study made a significant contribution to the existing literature. The study also provided recommendations for further research. The lived experience of first-time breastfeeding mothers.Qualitative Article Critique Paper details: Attached are the guidelines to develop the review, plus the article that need to be used Guidelines for Qualitative Nursing Research Critique Analyze and critique a quantitative nursing research article from a nursing research journal published within the past 5 years.
Qualitative Critique: Missed Nursing Care 5 Enhancement of Rigor. To enhance the validity of the data, it was analyzed by two different researchers independently of each other. One option is to consider writing a psychology critique paper of a published psychology book or academic journal article.
For example, you might write a critical analysis of Sigmund Freud's Interpretation of Dreams or you might evaluate a more recent book such as Philip Zimbardo's The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil.
Critique papers require students to conduct a critical analysis of another piece of writing, often a book, journal article, or essay. No matter what your major is, you will probably be expected to write a critique paper at some point.
Qualitative Critique of Psychology Paper. Print Reference this.
Disclaimer: This work has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional academic writers.
You can view samples of our professional work here. A Critique of the Qualitative Research: “Missed Nursing Care” Mamdouh Nakada Berea College Nur February 18, Beatrice J.
Kalisch, PhD, RN, FAAN, reports her qualitative study “Missed Nursing Care” on medical-surgical units in .